Mexican restaurants

The Supreme Burrito #1

4.5 812 reviews Closed 843 Dodge Ave, Evanston, IL 60202, United States

Discover this place

The Supreme Burrito #1, located in Evanston, IL, has quickly established itself as a local favorite for Mexican cuisine. With a diverse menu featuring everything from burritos to tacos, customers rave about the mouthwatering offerings. The burritos, starting at just $11.75, are crafted with fresh ingredients and come with a variety of fillings, including BBQ pork, carne asada, and vegetarian options. The standout item seems to be the handmade chorizo, highlighted in multiple reviews. Regular patrons appreciate not only the quality of the food but also the welcoming atmosphere. Many mention how the friendly staff contribute to a positive dining experience, making it a pleasant spot for both takeaway and sit-down meals. While the busy location can lead to limited seating and a quick turnover of patrons, diners agree that the fast service keeps the experience enjoyable. With generous portions at reasonable prices, such as the $15.35 burrito dinner served with rice, beans, and soda, The Supreme Burrito #1 is a gem for anyone craving authentic Mexican flavors. The blend of delicious food, swift service, and a warm community vibe make this eatery a must-try for locals and visitors alike.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

College students
Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with The Supreme Burrito #1 before visiting.

Reviews for The Supreme Burrito #1

4.5

812 reviews

100%

26%

Review highlights

Based on 812 reviews

Public reviews for The Supreme Burrito #1 consistently highlight its fresh, flavorful Mexican offerings, particularly praised for savory salsas, handmade chorizo, and well-prepared burritos. Customers appreciate the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it an appealing spot for both dining in and takeout. The service quality stands out, with frequent mentions of friendly, welcoming, and attentive staff who create a personable and engaging atmosphere. While the food is noted for its quick preparation and freshness, some feedback points to limited seating capacity, suggesting potential crowding during peak times. Overall, The Supreme Burrito #1 is regarded as a popular local favorite with a strong emphasis on quality ingredients and excellent customer relations.

Matthew Parrilli

May 09, 2025

Supreme Burrito #1 always hits the spot! Fresh & tasty burritos, savory salsas, and sublime guacamole & chips. The staff is always welcoming & friendly. Recommended for dining in or carrying out.

Kevin U

May 01, 2025

Mouthwatering food! Everything tastes so good. Plus the employees are really friendly and helpful. I felt very welcomed. I will definitely be back.

Axel Erk

Apr 19, 2025

Best handmade chorizo I’ve had in a while. My current favorite is a queen burrito, with everything but no cheese. The sour cream is supreme on its own in this burrito. The red or chile de arbol salsa is my favorite with any of their items. Get a cheese quesadilla as well, it’s worth it. The owner is nice and right to the point. Food is quick and piping hot, tortillas fresh and well toasted. Sorry guys. But this ones a destination I try to eat at as much as possible. Oh most people can’t love without the al pastor but el chorizo owns my heart

Dan Walker

Apr 19, 2025

Great food. Generous portions. Reasonable prices. Fast service. The thing that makes this place a standout though is the people. Super friendly and engaging. They remember you when you come back. Just a great local business. The only downside is that they need to expand. There’s not really room to eat in house unless you don’t mind people standing all around you waiting to order - they’re so popular there’s always a line, but it goes fast.

NMDER

Apr 13, 2025

I love getting a burrito here after my lessons at Robert Crown. The customer service is great, and the food is even better! Highly recommend!

Perry Myers

Mar 23, 2025

Good food at a fair price. Friendly staff. Burritos are generous and tasty. Small seating area but mostly take out business.

Jessica Harbinson

Mar 14, 2025

Delicious food! Have used them to cater 2 large events, everyone loved it!

Melinda Dworkin

Mar 08, 2025

Much appreciated in Evanston is this casual fast inexpensive yet quality ingredients Mexican restaurant, with late hours and a friendly atmosphere. Food is freshly prepared and so satisfyingly delicious. My favorites: an egg, cheese, avocado burrito, chicken tacos, carne asada burrito w/avocado, and most of all the homemade Chicken Soup.